: home : films : ratings : join : committee : links : contact us

Other seasons' ratings

2008/09 season's ratings  

 : 2009/10
 : 2008/09
 : 2007/08
 : 2006/07
 : 2005/06
 : 2004/05
 : 2003/04

Members and their guests are invited to rate each film, the results of which are shown below, together with any members' comments received.




The Band's Visit

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

32

41

5

1

1

"A very enjoyable film. So different. You were right, we certainly left with smiles on our faces." Keith Edwards




Into the Wild

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

44

13

3

0

1

"A moving film, well directed and filmed. At 2hr 25min, long but held our attention throughout. Can't think of any bits that should have been taken out - they all built up the complex character of the "supertramp". Excellent!" Phil & Gill Parkman

"In spite of its length, I thought this was a very poignant story, beautifully filmed - definitely needed to be seen on the big screen. Good choice." Amanda Helm

"Totally absorbing, totally gripping, total immersion. Excellent film, beautifully filmed, moving and even more poignant to see that it was based on a true story. I came to in the Queens Theatre and wondered what on Earth I was doing there." Roger Graham




Caramel

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

26

24

7

1

1

"A gentle but vivid portrayal of life in Beirut. More a ladies film or maybe my female side is undeveloped but I enjoyed it and came away feeling good, with my faith in human nature restored." Roger Graham




Jindabyne

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

25

18

11

3

1






Honeydripper

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

35

21

1

0

0






Lars and the real Girl

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

37

20

3

1

0

"A wacky but wonderful film, with good character development. Well acted and filmed. Very enjoyable (particularly now the sound level has been turned down below the threshold of pain - we oldies are not as deaf as the teenagers seem to be!!) Congratulations to the selection committee. Keep up the good work." Mr & Mrs Parkman




The Kite Runner

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

49

15

1

0

0






Persepolis

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

13

17

4

4

2






The Orphanage

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

15

10

2

1

5






Syriana

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

17

11

2

2

5





Summary for all films this season

Excellent

Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

293

190

39

13

16

53%

34%

7%

2%

3%




top

Site coding and text © CranbrookFilmSociety